The Sable Verity

You can disagree, but I’ll still be right

Elisabeth Fritzl faces long questioning about father, cellar

Elisabeth Fritzl, the Austrian woman who was held hostage in a cellar by her father for 24 years, has begun to tell her story to prosecutors, in the run-up to a trial in the worst recorded case of incest and imprisonment.

At a preliminary session with investigators on Friday, Elisabeth, 42, was taken to a secret location and shown the rooms where the intense interviewing sessions are to take place over several days or weeks. The questioning is due to begin in earnest tomorrow. Her evidence will be videotaped and played during the trial so that she will not have to face her father in court this winter.

Elisabeth had earlier backed out of an attempt to question her. She had been told that her father, Josef, 74, would be able to watch the sessions via a video link from his St Pölten prison cell and that he would be allowed to pose questions directly to her. She told investigators she was not ready to face him.

But Fritzl’s lawyer, Rudolf Mayer, has since declared that his client would waive his right to be present during the questioning, although he still has the chance to change his mind.

As Elisabeth recalls the years during which she was allegedly sexually abused by her father, tied up, and bore seven children to him without any medical attention, psychologists will be on hand and can insist that the interviewing is broken off at any time.

Elisabeth will be interviewed by Andrea Hummer, the young judge who will preside over the case and who is an expert in sexual crimes. In a neighbouring room, the interview will be watched by state prosecutor Christiane Burkheiser and Fritzl’s lawyer, both of whom will be able to pose questions to Elisabeth via Hummer. The scenario is one usually reserved for child victims of sexual abuse to protect them from further trauma.

‘The questioning will take place according to the state of mind of the witness,’ Gerhard Sedlacek, spokesman for the state prosecution service of St Pölten told Der Spiegel. ‘We waited until she was healthy enough to give evidence before beginning.’

At the end of the month, her oldest children, Stefan, 18, and Kerstin, 19 - who emerged from an artificially induced coma to the amazement of medical staff and her family last month - are also due to give evidence. They, along with Felix, five, were imprisoned with their mother in the cellar. Three other children - Lisa, 15, Monika, 14, and Alexander, 12 - whom Fritzl claimed his daughter had dropped on the family doorstep, asking him and his wife Rosemarie to take care of them, were brought up upstairs.

As the two parts of the family, who are living in a flat at a psychiatric clinic near their hometown of Amstetten, seek to build a new life together, it has been revealed that hospital staff have been regularly disguising the children and smuggling them past waiting photographers to take them on secret trips to learn about ordinary life and social interaction.

Lisa, 15, was even sent to a camp run by the fire brigade for the region’s youth after she wrote in May to Amstetten’s fire chief Armin Blutsch, expressing her ‘deepest wish’ to attend. Her name was changed to protect her identity, and she mixed with 4,000 children over four days and was able to meet school friends for the first time since the case came to light three months ago.

There are unconfirmed reports that Alexander was also sent to the camp. There have been trips to zoos and leisure parks, also following requests by the children. Felix, meanwhile, is being taught to swim in the clinic’s pool. ‘Fortunately, everything is going very well,’ said Christoph Herbst, the family’s lawyer.

Part of the children’s day is taken up with answering letters from the hundreds of well-wishers from around the world. Otherwise, the family has been enjoying walks in the hospital grounds and learning, above all, to be patient with each other.

Psychologists say that one of the greatest challenges has been for the ‘upstairs’ children to accept the slowness of the ‘downstairs’ children, whose lives revolved around a few books and a television set, and were played out in a tiny space devoid of artificial light or fresh air. The ‘downstairs’ children continue to be startled by seemingly mundane events like a moving cloud or a chirping bird.

For now, the focus is on the investigation. The key decision that must be made is what Fritzl, who has confessed to imprisoning Elisabeth and having children with her, can be charged with. A neonatologist is seeking to determine whether Fritzl can be charged with murder after DNA tests confirmed he was the father of a twin who died shortly after birth and whose body he allegedly threw into a furnace.

‘It will be difficult to bring a murder charge,’ Sedlacek admitted. ‘But we’ll leave no possibility unturned.’

If he is found guilty of murder along with kidnapping and rape, Fritzl faces life in prison. Without a murder conviction, he faces 10 to 15 years in jail, which, it is believed, would create a national and international outcry.

This article appeared in the Observer on Sunday July 13 2008 on p36 of the World news section. It was last updated at 00:00 on July 13 2008.

July 12, 2008 Posted by Sable | News | , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Fritzl children return to freedom while Josef preps for court

From MEDIndia:

In a delicious twist of irony, imprisoned Josef Fritzl insists on open air exercises in prison while his cellar children are slowly venturing out into the wide world outside.

Fritzl had kept his daughter Elisabeth locked in a cellar in Amstetten, Austria, and fathered her seven children before police caught him when he was forced to hospitalize one of the three brought up in the dungeon.

One of the seven died when very young, three were never allowed to leave the cellar even for a minute, while the other three went on to live with Fritzl as his adopted or fostered children.

Elisabeth, her children and her mother are getting treatment and counseling at a psychiatric clinic guarded by police since late April.

One of the children who lived upstairs — a 15-year-old girl — spent last weekend “incognito” at a youth fire brigade camp with 4,000 other youngsters and met up with some of her school friends for the first time in nearly three months.

Other family members also have made day trips outside under disguise, the Kurier newspaper reported.

Elisabeth has been questioned by prosecutors for the first time, it has been reported.

The Austria Press Agency, citing unidentified judicial sources, said 42-year-old Elisabeth Fritzl was interviewed Friday in a secret location.

Film of the interviews will be shown in court at the father’s trial later this year, Austrian media reported.

Fritzl himself has been making copious notes ready for the interview, as he will be present when Elisabeth speaks via a video link up and will be allowed to ask questions via his lawyer.

And the man who locked away his daughter in a windowless cellar for 24 years, has asked permission to leave his prison cell, saying he can no longer stand being cooped up.

Prison spokesman Lieutenant Colonel Erich Huber-Guensthofer said: “Mr Fritzl is accommodated in a cell for two and recently he has made use of his right to go outside for half an hour per day.

“He usually sits there watching television all day, especially news programmes about him,” said one prison source. “He’s terrified that someone will attack him or try to kill him.”

July 12, 2008 Posted by Sable | News | , , , , , , , , | No Comments

Breaking: Elisabeth Fritzl gives testimony to Austrian authorities

This, from the BBC:

Legal authorities in Austria have begun questioning Elisabeth Fritzl, the woman who was held captive in a cellar for 24 years by her father, Josef.

The questioning involved a doctor to determine how one of the seven babies she was forced to bear by her father had died, said the prosecutor’s office.

Mr Fritzl confessed to incinerating the body of the dead baby, officials say.

Formal charges against Josef Fritzl may be ready within a few months - allowing a trial to start later this year.

The interview is being filmed so that Elisabeth Fritzl will not have to give evidence in person in court, officials said.

It is not clear how long the questioning will last or where it is taking place.

Possible murder charge

Mr Fritzl is being held in pre-trial detention in St Poelten, 80 km (50 miles) west of the capital, Vienna.

His alleged victims, including Elisabeth, 42, are undergoing treatment at a psychiatric hospital.

Prosecutors say Mr Fritzl has confessed to keeping his daughter captive in a cell at his home in Amstetten, where he says he had seven children with her.Three of the children were confined to the cellar, three were raised above ground, and one died in infancy, officials say.

Mr Fritzl confessed to disposing of the child’s corpse - a twin born in 1997 - and could face murder charges if he is found responsible for the death, officials say.

DNA tests have shown he is the father of Elisabeth’s six surviving children.

The case first came to light after Kerstin, one of the children fathered by Mr Fritzl, became seriously ill and was taken to hospital.

Unable to find any medical records, they appealed for the teenager’s mother to come forward.

At that point Mr Fritzl released Elisabeth, who then explained the story to police.

Kerstin was finally reunited with her family after coming out of a coma earlier this month. She is expected to make a full recovery.

 

July 11, 2008 Posted by Sable | News | , , , , , , , , | No Comments

Josef Fritzl “going crazy” from confinement

From the Telegraph, UK:

Josef Fritzl, who locked his daughter in a cellar dungeon for 24 years, has asked permission to leave his prison cell after admitting he can no longer stand being cooped up.

Fritzl, 73, kept daughter Elisabeth locked in a windowless cellar in Amstetten, Austria, and fathered her seven children before being caught by police. Three of the children had never seen daylight before being released.

Now, after just two months of incarceration and despite his fear of being attacked by fellow prisoners, he has demanded his right to 30 minutes exercise every day.

Fritzl has now twice had half-hour walks, protected from other inmates by a close guard of prison officers.

Prison spokesman Lieutenant Colonel Erich Huber-Guensthofer said: “Mr Fritzl is accommodated in a cell for two and recently he has made use of his right to go outside for half an hour per day.

“He usually sits there watching television all day, especially news programmes about him,” said one prison source. “He’s terrified that someone will attack him or try to kill him.”

Prosecutors are about to interview Elisabeth, 42, and expect to put her father on trial in September.

Fritzl has been making copious notes ready for the interview, as he will be present when Elisabeth speaks via a video link up and will be allowed to ask questions via his lawyer.

 

July 11, 2008 Posted by Sable | News | , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Up-to-date coverage on Austria’s Elisabeth Fritzl and family

Recently I have been gently scolded by folks who visit the site specifically for updates on Elisabeth et al, because I have not been updating this particular threat with all of the links in it.  I sincerely apologize for that, and will strive to be better.

Listed from newest coverage to oldest coverage:

Josef only faces ten years for crimes

Doctor’s permit Elisabeth to testify this month

Formal charges still months away for Josef

Josef seeks highest bidder for memoirs

Elisabeth may file lawsuit for privacy

Breaking News: Josef Fritzl now writing tell-all book- July 6, 2008

Is Josef Fritzl a victim too?

Josef Fritzl: Extreme Egoism

Josef Fritzl trial in 2008

Is Elisabeth “refusing” to testify against Fritzl?

Doctors say Elisabeth not prepared to testify

Read more »

July 10, 2008 Posted by Sable | News | , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Outrage: Josef Fritzl will face 10 years for crimes against Elisabeth, her children

From the Telegraph, UK:

Fritzl, 73, has already confessed to imprisoning his daughter Elisabeth, 42, in the cellar in his home in Amstetten, Austria, and fathering her seven children.

He is facing potential charges of rape, incarceration, incest and manslaughter, as one of the children died shortly after birth in 1997 and Fritzl burned his body in an incinerator.

However, unlike in Britain and America, the Austrian penal code does not allow for cumulated convictions, meaning Fritzl will only serve the punishment for the offence that carries the longest prison sentence.

And according to prosecutors, manslaughter and the rape charges will be difficult to prove due to the elapse of time and lack of evidence.

The only charge Fritzl is certain to face is incarceration, for having kept his daughter and their children in the dank cellar for 24 years, an offence that can only be sentenced with 10 years in prison in Austria.

A spokesman for the prosecution said: “Manslaughter will be very difficult to prove as there is no forensic or any other kind of evidence available since the suspected crime happened many years ago.

“Such charges would require evidence that the suspect acted with premeditation and that he knew there was danger of the newborn dying after birth.”

“The charges of rape will also be difficult to prove, due to the absence of any objective evidence and would therefore probably only be based on the statement of the victim, who has not yet given evidence to the prosecutors.”

 

July 10, 2008 Posted by Sable | News | , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment